the proposal faces several serious hurdles, such as attributing blame where internet access is shared, and then determining what is illegal content. Although BitTorrent traffic is primarily pirated material, there is also increasing amounts of legal material as well. Even this week a German record company offered its entire music catalog via Pirate Bay, so even using and accessing material from the most famed pirate site of them all may not actually constitute downloading illegal material.
even Francois Copé, leader in the National Assembly of Sarkozy’s UMP, has backtracked on three-strikes law,to quote him
“Illegal downloading will be marginalised, not by restrictive legislation, but by technological progress and changing patterns of usage.”