The Macrosite for News, Analysis and Opinion about the Future of the Internet
Daniel Castro

Cybersecurity Challenge Calls for Multilevel Plan

Written by Daniel Castro
6/1/2009 6 comments
DISCUSS   Digg   Del.icio.us   Reddit   Email This   TWEET THIS

On Friday, May 29, the Obama administration announced the results of the 60-day review on cybersecurity conducted by Melissa Hathaway and laid out new priorities for cybersecurity.

Overall, the report delivers a solid overview of the current challenges and presents next steps for grappling with them. Key portions of this strategy include creating a "Cyber Czar" to oversee national cybersecurity initiatives; public-private partnerships to better share data and resources; efforts to create and retain a skilled cybersecurity work force; and plans to increase public awareness of cybersecurity threats and challenges.

The report's near-term action plan also includes updating the national strategy to secure cyberspace; developing a framework for additional research and development of security technology; and preparing a cybersecurity incident response plan.

The fact that the Obama administration is making this a priority speaks volumes about the growing need to secure our critical infrastructure. With two wars, a growing nuclear threat from North Korea, and a still-struggling economy, the President already has more than enough to keep him busy. But many important policy objectives of this administration rely on digital infrastructure -- from modernizing the healthcare system with electronic medical records to building a "smart" energy grid.

Government leadership is needed to make this happen. But responsibility for cybersecurity should not rest with any single government agency, as it has become an important component across all agencies. In particular, this responsibility should not be usurped by the defense agencies, because the threats are much broader than national security.

In addition, many cybersecurity activities need to remain unclassified for continued innovation and adoption on non-military systems. The Pentagon has already released new plans to build a cyber command center to conduct both offensive and defensive online computer warfare. A national cybersecurity strategy needs to be much broader than this and address the broader economic and consumer issues raised by these online threats.

For example, government needs to work with industry to develop secure systems for electronic medical records; but it needs to work even harder to get healthcare providers to start using those systems and make sure the systems are interoperable. Similarly, the electric grid should be secured from online attacks by foreign adversaries, but the more pressing priorities are to upgrade the transmission and distribution networks to increase their overall performance and reliability.

But the path forward will also require new thinking and new ideas. The past problems with cybersecurity were not simply a lack of sufficient government involvement. Nor will these problems be solved by merely shuffling around the government hierarchy.

Government agencies need to actively partner with the private sector to identify risks and mitigate threats as a necessary component of a national cybersecurity strategy. Private industry controls many of the networks, hardware, and software that make up our national digital infrastructure, and it will continue to be on the frontlines of any efforts to improve cybersecurity.

Government also needs to work with industry to facilitate better data sharing and develop better metrics for risk management. Likewise, citizen engagement and education will similarly be important; otherwise, the weakest link will be the American citizen. While attempts to hack into the electric grid are more likely to show up on the president's daily brief, consumers must contend daily with other cybersecurity threats, such as spam, malware attacks, phishing, and identity theft. Fortunately, the administration seems to recognize the limitations of the federal government working alone and has indicated that it will work closely with the private sector on many of these issues.

At the end of the day, the cybersecurity strategy outlined by the new administration will be just one part of a global effort to make digital infrastructure more secure. Just as global climate change cannot be solved by a single country, neither can one nation solve all of the cybersecurity challenges of this century.

Although it has the opportunity to become a global leader on the issue, the United States will be just one country among many working to address cybersecurity threats. But it does have an important role to play in encouraging innovation, setting standards, and building partnerships with other nations.

One more thing: Words matter, but so do actions. The administration has laid out a bold plan for cybersecurity -- now we will have to wait to see how well it can execute this vision.

— Daniel Castro is a Senior Analyst with the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation (ITIF)

DISCUSS   Digg   Del.icio.us   Reddit   Email This
Current display:       newest comments first       display in chronological order
lenrosen
Rank: Cave Painter
Wednesday June 3, 2009 7:43:47 PM
no ratings

The best outcome is the level of focus on issues related to the importance of the network and Internet infrastructure and the part it plays in the modern world. It's good to have a President who walks the walk in technology usage, and has a basic understanding of the complexities involved in creating what to so many users seems so transparently simple, such as a Google Search.

Mark Odiorne
Rank: Cyborg
Wednesday June 3, 2009 6:44:03 PM
no ratings

They don't need a czar to dictate from on high, they need a coordinator with a great project management staff. Someone who can speak multiple languages (government, business and 'real world') and "herd cats". Has to be respected by all sides and willing to speak the truth.

A guy can dream, can't he?

Mark Odiorne
Rank: Cyborg
Wednesday June 3, 2009 6:36:58 PM
no ratings

Smart people don't always make smart decisions, they make business decisions. Security is almost always an afterthought, bolted on at the end. Bruce Schneier said it very well when he said that there will always be a struggle between security and "getting the work done" because security often gets in the way of the real business of the organization - and the business side most often will win. Until the pain of poor security outweighs the benefits of ignoring it.

no ratings

I don't know if you read the speech the President gave but he began his remarks with a revelation that during the run up to the election hackers managed to penetrate his computer campaign systems, gaining access to emails, campaign files, policy postion papers and travel plans.

The President stated that the fundraising website was at no time compromised but to deal with the security breaches, the team had to call for assistancefrom the FBI, CIA, Secret Service and a number of private consultants to ensure the security of the system.

When you consider the brain power behind the Obama Campaign's web presence, I found this revelation to be disturbing. If that team couldn't anticipate security problems in their network design, what does that mean for the rest of us?

 

 

Terry Sweeney
IQ Crew
Tuesday June 2, 2009 1:16:23 PM
no ratings

A bevy of names are floating to the surface as potential nominess for the new cybersecurity position that Obama envisions, including:

  • Rear Admiral Robert C. “Willie” Williamson, USN (Ret) who's currently Director, Naval Integration and Transformation at Raytheon
  • Paul B. Kurtz, online and homeland security expert, and served in previous White House positions under both Clinton and Bush.
  • Roger Cressey, founder of Good Harbor Consulting and also a veteran of the Clinton and Bush administrations.
  • Richard A. Clarke, security gadlfy, author, battle-scarred White House staffer
  • And for those at home keeping score, the Department of Homeland Security also finally filled Rod Beckstrom's old job and appointed a few other DHS cybersecurity hands.

    Mary Jander
    Thinkernetter
    Tuesday June 2, 2009 10:12:15 AM
    no ratings

    I'm with the gang who've provided the most responses to our latest poll. I would like to think that the Washington bureaucracy could overcome its insularity and political biases long enough to make this work. On the other hand, they've spoiled other admirable projects and there's no reason to believe they won't dig in on this one.

    At least this move has spurred public attention to the urgency of cybersecurity.

    The ThinkerNet does not reflect the views of TechWeb. The ThinkerNet is an informal means of communication to members and visitors of the Internet Evolution site. Individual authors are chosen by Internet Evolution to blog. Neither Internet Evolution nor TechWeb assume responsibility for comments, claims, or opinions made by authors and ThinkerNet bloggers. They are no substitute for your own research and should not be relied upon for trading or any other purpose.
    previous posts from Daniel Castro
    Daniel Castro
    Daniel Castro   5/26/2009   8 comments
    A recent article in The Washington Post has called into question the role of the private sector in setting standards for electronic health record (EHR) systems. Specifically, the article questions the appropriateness of allowing a group that originally pushed for stimulus funds to now have an oversight role in how those funds are spent.
    5
    of
    IETV: the thinkerNet on film
    5
    of
    2pm EDT
    Thu
    Sep 30th
    an IBM information resource
    sponsored content
    big blue blog
    an IBM information resource
    sponsored content
    Getting to Work on Smart Work: How IT Is Transforming the Implementation of the 'Internet of Things'
    Organizations in all industry sectors are becoming more instrumented, interconnected, and intelligent -- and that's changing the way they approach virtually every facet of their operations. It's up to IT to help organizations adopt a "Three I's" approach that leverages the emerging Internet of Things and enables them to work smarter.

    READ THIS eBOOK
    your weekly update of news, analysis, and
    opinion from Internet Evolution - FREE!

    REGISTER HERE
    Wanted! Site Moderators
    Internet Evolution is looking for a handful of readers to help moderate the message boards on our site – as well as engaging in high-IQ conversation with the industry mavens on our thinkerNet blogosphere. The job comes with various perks, bags of kudos, and GIANT bragging rights. Interested?

    Please email: moderators@internetevolution.com
    Internet Evolution – not for thickies
    Cloud Computing Requires a Change of Mind
    Sean Gallagher
    In what now seems like the ancient history of the technology industry,
    Sun Microsystems Inc. co-founder Scott McNealy talked about a future with “application dial tone.” Virtualization and cloud computing are getting us closer to that today, but there are still some major obstacles -- and many of them aren't technical.

    CLICK FOR MORE
    Apple's 'Terrorware' Patent Could Turn 2010 Into 1984
    Alan Reiter
    Forget about
    Apple Inc. (Nasdaq: AAPL)’s announcements of the new Apple TV, iPods, and Ping. It's kid stuff compared to what Apple has in store for you.

    CLICK FOR MORE
    Cisco-Skype Deal Rumors Run Rampant
    Ron Miller
    Last week,
    TechCrunch broke a rumor that Cisco Systems Inc. (Nasdaq: CSCO) has made a bid for Skype Ltd. Never mind that as recently as Friday, neither Cisco nor Skype would discuss the matter. Not that these noncommittal “official comments” mean much. The rumor was in the breeze, and that set people speculating about what this might mean for both companies.

    CLICK FOR MORE
    Second Shooter
    Collaboration & Spherical Stupidity

    2|24|10   |   2:12   |   18 comments


    A recent scandal involving a school's use of remotely activated Webcams to locate lost or stolen laptops may portend, not only legal action against the school, but also a loss of trust in video that is critical to developing video collaboration over the Internet.
    Second Shooter
    Less Competition, Lower Broadband Pricing?

    9|7|10   |   2:13   |   No comments


    Because 25% to 45% of broadband cost is due to sales and marketing, we could reduce our broadband prices by eliminating advertising and promotional spending by providers.
    Reiter's Block
    RIM Caving on Security

    9|2|10   |   2:32   |   4 comments


    RIM is giving in to demands by India to snoop on encrypted BlackBerry data. It's time to develop cheap or free encryption software for BlackBerrys and other cellular phones.
    Second Shooter
    More Internet? No Thanks!

    8|13|10   |   2:09   |   10 comments


    Pew says that 53% of the US population doesn't think broadband policy is necessary. Other data shows that most consumers who don't have the Internet just don’t want it. Perhaps the Internet’s problem has more to do with content than policy. Hmmmmmm...
    Second Shooter
    Your Privacy vs. Google

    8|11|10   |   2:10   |   2 comments


    Google's problems in Korea and the leaked internal document on exploiting private data show that, if we want to avoid active regulation, we need more explicit disclosure of what companies do and don’t do with what they collect.
    Reiter's Block
    FBI Takes Cue From French Nobility

    8|4|10   |   02:43   |   4 comments


    The FBI wants authority to obtain certain Internet information from ISPs without a court order. What is this, the French nobility? Sacré bleu!
    Reiter's Block
    UAE Wants to Snoop on BlackBerry Users

    8|2|10   |   3:11   |   26 comments


    RIM is under pressure from the United Arab Emirates to allow the country to snoop on BlackBerry messages. Alan thinks RIM should refuse.
    Second Shooter
    Blame Wall Street for Your Broadband Problems

    7|23|10   |   2:05   |   No comments


    Our broadband futures aren't dependent on what's under our streets but rather on what's inside the heads of Wall Street. (Uh oh.) Without long-term investments in infrastructure, better broadband is merely a pipe dream.
    Second Shooter
    What's in a Name? Not Enough!

    7|20|10   |   2:07   |   6 comments


    'What's in a name?' is more than rhetoric. It's a fundamental question about the real meaning of 'Identity' in a global, online world.
    Cirque Du Solez
    Want Net Happiness? Take Control!

    7|19|10   |   2:00   |   6 comments


    An email from Ukraine teaches us that perhaps those who complain about the Internet just haven’t figured out how to spam people’s inboxes with requests for pens and balloons… or something.
    Cirque Du Solez
    Human-Machine Co-Evolution: Weird!

    9|8|10   |   3:06   |   1 comment


    To prove a point about human-machine co-evolution, Ol' Doc Solez co-evolves in the middle of this video blog. Maybe.
    Aneesh Chopra
    Top IT Challenges for the USA

    9|8|10   |   02:52   |   1 comment


    Supporting mobile broadband is the top IT challenge for the top IT guy in the nation.
    Mary E. Shacklett
    Wish List for Mobile Devices, Part 2

    Part 2 of 2   |  
    See complete series
    9|7|10   |   1:53   |   1 comment


    High on the list of desired improvements from the mobile industry are: shared digital storage for the Internet; phone capability across borders; reduced electro-magnetic radiation; and rewards-based service plans.
    Second Shooter
    Less Competition, Lower Broadband Pricing?

    9|7|10   |   2:13   |   No comments


    Because 25% to 45% of broadband cost is due to sales and marketing, we could reduce our broadband prices by eliminating advertising and promotional spending by providers.
    Reiter's Block
    OED Heads for a Paperless Future

    9|6|10   |   02:50   |   4 comments


    The next edition of one of the greatest English language reference books, the "Oxford English Dictionary," might not be published in paper. Bibliophiles might mourn, but should they?
    what.the.ferraro
    Guilty of Foolish Facebookery

    9|3|10   |   01:40   |   11 comments


    Again we learn the hard way that people serving on jury duty should stay far away from the World Wide Web.
    Reiter's Block
    RIM Caving on Security

    9|2|10   |   2:32   |   4 comments


    RIM is giving in to demands by India to snoop on encrypted BlackBerry data. It's time to develop cheap or free encryption software for BlackBerrys and other cellular phones.
    Wisdom of the Big Chair
    More Texting, Less Bandwidth

    9|2|10   |   1:56   |   1 comment


    Nielsen’s recent numbers on the increasing use of texting bode well for enterprise networks. Shunning the phone in favor of text messaging could mean reducing bandwidth.
    Second Shooter
    Taking Copyright Protection Too Far

    9|1|10   |   2:08   |   7 comments


    Two studios have filed suit against an ad broker for placing ads to help monetize P2P sites suspected of copyright infringement. That's taking a dangerous step toward what might be a worthy goal.
    Singer at C-Level
    Video in the Cloud

    9|1|10   |   2:16   |   3 comments


    Software giants are looking for cloud solutions to support our insatiable appetite for video. There will be blood. Yum.

    Enabling People and Organizations to Harness the Transformative Power of Technology