The Macrosite for News, Analysis and Opinion about the Future of the Internet
Andrew Odlyzko

The Internet's Role in Alleviating the Energy Crises

Written by Andrew Odlyzko
4/8/2008 3 comments
DISCUSS   Digg   Del.icio.us   Reddit   Email This   TWEET THIS

The Internet has long been touted as a major weapon in reducing road congestion, through enabling and stimulating telecommuting. More recently, it has been promoted as a means to fight global warming.  But these hopes fly in the face of centuries of experience.  It is likely that the Internet will play a major role in alleviating problems caused by several energy crises that we face, but this will not take place as commonly expected.

There has been widespread expectation that communication and transportation are substitutes for each other. There is a direct stimulation effect -- for example, higher capacity on fiber cables enables offshoring jobs to India. But the workers there have to be trained, supervised, and coordinated, which means a jump in air travel to and from India.

There are also improvements from one technology that are absorbed into another (computer and communications improvements led to better and much less expensive printers, which satisfied the latent demand for printing on the desktop -- and made a mockery of the "paperless office" concept). 

All these combine to yield a simple observation, with overwhelming evidence going back centuries, that as society develops economically, both communication and transportation boom.  They are both services whose consumption grows with technological and economic advances.  (For extensive compilation of evidence on the spread of various communication technologies in synergy with apparent competitors, see my 2000 manuscript, "The history of communications and its implications for the Internet.")

Thus simply deploying the Internet more widely and with increased capacity is likely, in the absence of other developments, to stimulate travel and energy usage. This would be true even without counting the energy usage of the Internet and the computers connected to it.

The centuries of experience where both communication and transportation have grown vigorously were also centuries in which energy has been getting steadily less expensive (in inflation-adjusted terms) and more convenient to use.  Human society started with wood, and then went on to coal, oil, and natural gas.  But there does not seem to be any successor to these, at least in the short term.  Instead, we appear to face three serious threats, any one of which can drive up the cost of energy by itself: 

  1. Rapid growth in the developing world: With China's economy growing at 10 percent, and India not much less, the traditional rate of technological improvement in economic efficiency and the rate of discovery of new energy sources can't keep up. 
  2. "Peak oil": The widely predicted, although still controversial, start of a decline in total world oil production. 
  3. Global warming: Surely no need to explain. 

So, unless all three of the energy threats above are avoided, the price of energy will continue to go up.  And if energy becomes more expensive, the Internet may become a substitute for transportation (as well as an aid towards greater efficiency in a variety of ways), not because that is the usual outcome, but enforced by drastically changed circumstances.  So in that sense, the advocacy of greater broadband deployment may be very productive.

But it will be a very different world than the one that led to our current technological and economic state.  We may drive less, but not because we love to telecommute, or because we are tired of traffic jams, but because the costs will get too high.  Many of the rules we relied on to judge economic and technological developments will simply not apply.

— Andrew Odlyzko, Director, Interdisciplinary Digital Technology Center, University of Minnesota 

DISCUSS   Digg   Del.icio.us   Reddit   Email This
Current display:       newest comments first       display in chronological order
RPR
IQ Crew
Thursday April 10, 2008 4:53:19 PM
no ratings

Andrew, does the following stated in your 2000 manuscript hold in '08 and will it in 2020?

Whether content is king or not has direct relevance for the question of whether the Internet will continue to be an open network, or whether it will be balkanized. If content were to dominate, then the Internet would be primarily a broadcast network. With value proportional to the number of users, there would be few inherent advantages to an open network. The sum of the values of several completely or partially separate networks would be the same as of a unified network.

RPR
IQ Crew
Thursday April 10, 2008 3:54:18 PM
no ratings

Thought you may enjoy reading this; btw, Kudos, well said:

"it sometimes takes economic issues to convince a person to take socially responsible and pro-environmental actions" — Murugan 

Murugan
IQ Crew
Thursday April 10, 2008 11:34:43 AM
no ratings

You make an excellent point that it sometimes takes economic issues to convince a person to take socially responsible and pro-environmental actions.

The misconception is that pro-environmental issues harms progress in industry however, the short term gain from following fallacy often does more harm than good.  This often leaves one set of participants from being hurt either economically or even their health such as in the case of avoiding environmental safety by polluting the waterways.

When one takes the socially responsible path, all participants involved in a particular transaction benefit and obtain some kind of a value from it.

Perhaps, initially, flights will be required to send someone to train another person in some far away place but, once that training has been met, would you then say the environmental benefits from telecommuting becomes closer to pure?

In terms, of increased energy consumption, alternative forms of renewable energy would be the answer.

The ThinkerNet does not reflect the views of TechWeb. The ThinkerNet is an informal means of communication to members and visitors of the Internet Evolution site. Individual authors are chosen by Internet Evolution to blog. Neither Internet Evolution nor TechWeb assume responsibility for comments, claims, or opinions made by authors and ThinkerNet bloggers. They are no substitute for your own research and should not be relied upon for trading or any other purpose.
previous posts from Andrew Odlyzko
Andrew Odlyzko
Andrew Odlyzko   2/25/2008   11 comments
Is the Internet about to collapse from a flood of traffic? Or is it suffering from too little traffic? The growing media hype, with its frequent references to exafloods of video choking the Internet, uniformly points to the former. But Internet traffic growth, while still vigorous, has been slowing down, and the latter may be the more serious threat.
5
of
IETV: the thinkerNet on film
5
of
2pm EST
Tue
Dec 1st
an IBM information resource
sponsored content
big blue blog
Todd Watson
Todd Watson   11/20/2009   Post a comment
While Google introduces its new Chrome OS (which I'm hearing will be widely available in one year?  Did I mishear that?), IBM announced 10 new products today to help companies using IBM System z mainframe technology.
white papers & case studies
an IBM information resource
sponsored content
Smarter Collaboration: How to Thrive in a Challenging Business Environment
Market conditions are changing faster than ever, and organizations need to improve their agility and adaptability in order to provide better service and improve processes. The ability to work with customers, business partners, and employees as effectively as possible - while at the same time holding down costs - is a key to success.

READ THIS eBOOK
your weekly update of news, analysis, and
opinion from Internet Evolution - FREE!

REGISTER HERE
Wanted! Site Moderators
Internet Evolution is looking for a handful of readers to help moderate the message boards on our site – as well as engaging in high-IQ conversation with the industry mavens on our thinkerNet blogosphere. The job comes with various perks, bags of kudos, and GIANT bragging rights. Interested?

Please email: moderators@internetevolution.com
Copyright © 2009 United Business Media Limited - All rights reserved.      About Us  |  Privacy Policy and Terms of Use  |  Contact Us
CMP Media LLC
Internet Evolution – not for thickies
Not Dr. Phil
Internet & TV in Perfect Harmony?

11|16|09   |   2:22   |   3 comments


A new set-top offers an Internet experience without screwing up what we like about TV.
what.the.ferraro
Developers Take Google to Task

11|5|09   |   1:53   |   7 comments


The Google backlash continues. After seeing their Project 10^100 submissions disappear into the bowels of a Google server farm, a group of irate developers has started their own site to re-collect and vote on the ideas.
Tom Nolle
Getting Broadband Empowerment Right

10|22|09   |   2:19   |   2 comments


The FCC is throwing money at rural broadband empowerment, but it's dealing with the wrong problem. The real issue is how we get users who could get broadband but choose to reject it to change their minds. The answer lies with mobile technology – but it may surprise you!
Steve Saunders' Outernet
The Coming Internet Bubble: Part 2

Part 2 of 2   |  
See complete series
10|16|09   |   3:38   |   18 comments


How do you recognize an Internet bubble when you see one? Saunders explains how all bubbles have four symptoms in common – and takes a swipe at Google and Twitter into the bargain.
Steve Saunders' Outernet
The Coming Internet Bubble: Part 1

Part 1 of 2   |  
See complete series
10|14|09   |   1:54   |   16 comments


The sky is falling! And in other news, Saunders explains why he’s predicting a second Internet bubble – this one based around the current craze for social media.
TeleGraham
China's Broadband Revolution

10|13|09   |   2:36   |   1 comment


China is investing heavily in fiber to the premises to propel itself into the world broadband Internet first division. What's it deploying, and what's it going to do with all that bandwidth?
Steve Saunders' Outernet
Global Internet Growth: Part 2

Part 2 of 2   |  
See complete series
10|9|09   |   2:28   |   No comments


Saunders predicts the decline and fall of America’s Internet empire, and explains how the Internet of the future will be multi-lingual as well as multi-national.
Steve Saunders' Outernet
Global Internet Growth: Part 1

Part 1 of 2   |  
See complete series
10|7|09   |   1:24   |   4 comments


Saunders explains how Internet users in North America are already vastly outnumbered by those in the rest of the world – a situation which is only set to accelerate.
Singer at C-Level
Smart Grid Opportunities

11|20|09   |   2:49   |   No comments


Industry initiatives and government stimulus funds are giving enterprise software vendors a great opportunity to help build out and manage smart grid technologies.
Reiter's Block
Tweeting for Customer Support

11|18|09   |   2:20   |   No comments


When Reiter gets incensed over incompetent Verizon FiOS order-taking and support, he broadcasts it via Twitter. Did it do any good? How should your company offer Twitter support? Watch this for all the answers.
what.the.ferraro
Facebook Lacks Social Skills

11|20|09   |   1:53   |   No comments


Facebook's 'Suggestions' for users demonstrate how little social networking sites understand about true social relationships.
Singer at C-Level
Smart Grid Opportunities

11|20|09   |   2:49   |   No comments


Industry initiatives and government stimulus funds are giving enterprise software vendors a great opportunity to help build out and manage smart grid technologies.
Tom Nolle
Total Telephony Transcends Telepresence

11|20|09   |   2:11   |   2 comments


The problem with telepresence is that it's not universally accepted, because video calling isn't. While we can all do video calling, we also apparently worry too much about how we look. If we want HD telepresence in our future, we have to dress down, mess up our hair, and dive into our online life.
what.the.ferraro
ThinkerNet Wins Min's Award for Best Blogs!

11|19|09   |   1:13   |   4 comments


ThinkerNet wins the Min's award for 'Best Blogs' – Internet Evolution's fifth award this year!
Full Nelson
SanFran.gov

11|19|09   |   8:51   |   No comments


Fritz has an exclusive talk with the mayor and CTO of San Francisco about that city's latest e-government efforts.
Robert D. Atkinson
America Has Much to Learn About Digital Piracy

11|18|09   |   2:09   |   No comments


The US loses about $20 billion a year on pirated software, movies, and music. But public policy can help stem the tide of digital theft. For example, France has recently passed a 'three strikes and you’re out' law, whereby if after two warning letters an individual continues to download pirated software then his Internet access will be cut off. US policy makers should consider adopting similar policies.
Singer at C-Level
Connecting Stakeholders: Part 3

Part 3 of 3   |  
See complete series
11|18|09   |   2:09   |   No comments


Financial management planning does not need to include Voodoo economics, but it does help to tap into the knowledge base of your team through some sort of real-time system. We explore your options.
Reiter's Block
Tweeting for Customer Support

11|18|09   |   2:20   |   No comments


When Reiter gets incensed over incompetent Verizon FiOS order-taking and support, he broadcasts it via Twitter. Did it do any good? How should your company offer Twitter support? Watch this for all the answers.
what.the.ferraro
Dogster.com More Popular Than Gov 2.0

11|17|09   |   2:05   |   1 comment


A lot of attention is being paid to launching Gov 2.0 Websites, but these sites aren't attracting a lot of visitors.
Reiter's Block
Is the BlackBerry 9700 'Bold' Enough?

11|17|09   |   3:07   |   4 comments


The successor to the BlackBerry Bold 9000 – the Bold 9700 – will be available soon in the US. Is it worth upgrading? Reiter's got one, and offers advice.
TechWeb The Global Leader In Technology Media