The Macrosite for News, Analysis and Opinion about the Future of the Internet
Todd Watson

SXSW Interactive 2010: Clay Shirky Keynote Debrief

Written by Todd Watson
3/15/2010 1 comment
no ratings
DISCUSS   Digg   Del.icio.us   Reddit   Email This   TWEET THIS

The title of NYU ITP professor and author Clay Shirky's Sunday morning keynote was enough for a major draw: "Monkeys with Internet Access: Sharing, Human Nature, and Digital Data."

And amusing as the title was, the session was serious enough to jump up straight to the top of my personal SXSW Billboard charts for best session, because it was a session that got down beneath all the pixels, HTML code, and social media splatter to really focus on the underlying human motives that drive our behavior, in the digital realm and off.

After thanking the sleepy audience for "getting vertical so early" on a Sunday morning, Shirky explained his talk would be broken into three key segments: Buses and Bibles, Monkeys and Balloons, and Lingerie and Garbage.

He started his talk explaining that oftentimes, our recommended approaches to solving problems are too simplistic. Congested traffic? Build more and bigger roads. Or provide better public transportation as a viable alternative.

But as in the case of PickupPal, a ride-sharing service in Ottawa, the inclination toward sharing (in this case, providing information for ride shares) existing code (in this case, laws) can conflict with the opportunity for efficiency (getting people from point A to B with limited utilization of petroleum and the roadway).

In other words, PickupPal was too efficient to be legal, and the Ottawans had to change the law to accommodate its excellent opportunity for efficiency.

This was really a fight about sharing, and how much efficiency could be allowed.

Gutenberg was another example. His original product was the selling of published indulgences, and the press was originated to enable the publishing of more indulgences faster and cheaper (as opposed to those published by handwritten scribes).

Soon, Gutenberg turned to publishing Bibles and Martin Luther's Theses, and before you know it, the Protestant Reformation was in full bloom (and as a reaction, the scribes begin writing slower). By 1600, Catholicism was simply another religion.

Shirky's point: Abundance breaks more things than scarcity.

When things are scarce, we know how to deal with them. When they're abundant, the price goes away. Things we previously thought were scarce we don't know how to price or value.

In this case, it was bad news for the scribes, and ultimately the medium destroyed the message.

Flash forward a few hundred years and enter Napster, the fastest growing software in history (in 1998-99). It garnered more than 70 million users in a very short period of time, and it had not a trace of geekiness anywhere.

At the time, the crime rate had fallen to historic lows, and it was only the "theft" of recorded music via digital means that was a major issue. Shirky compared this to the sharing of primates, who had different modes of sharing for good, services, and information, the last being the most frictionless.

And in Napster's case, all it had done was to take a world of music that had previously been constituted as a good or service (something you could buy), and instead turned it into one of information (something you could easily share with no real cost to you).

Here's this song for so-and-so, put it online, and watch it take on a life of its own. Like monkeys, we have positive feelings about sharing information with one another -- we're biased to like doing so, which completely freaked the music industry out.

We do NOT voluntarily withhold information if sharing it made someone else happy, and this was the case with Napster.

We didn't voluntarily withhold information if sharing it made somebody else's life easier, because the barriers to doing so were low and we like helping others if it takes no greater effort on our part.

But in this case the music industry shocked and spiteful when we didn't do what they wanted us to do: not share.

Shirky then launched into the "Balloons" part of his talk, referring to the DARPA Big Red Balloon Challenge.

Last December DARPA said they would give away $50,000 to anyone who could identify the lat/long of ten large red balloons.

They figured it would take up to a month for someone to identify all ten. A team from MIT found them in about ten hours.

But to help with the find, there was a need to have a link to a spherical trigonometry formula that would help seekers with accounting for the earth's spherical shape in their quest. Where did DARPA link to?

Wikipedia. Why? Because a link to the same article on the online Britannica would have required registration, etc. Wikipedia was faster, cheaper, better. Wikipedia was all about sharing.

Finally, Shirky moved into the Lingerie and Garbage section, starting with references to "LOLcats" and the three wolfs howling at the moon T-shirt phenomenon, but ended up in some very serious situations around the globe, one where people have taken to sharing to create civic value and to help change the culture participants find themselves embedded in.

Places like PatientsLikeMe.Com, where patients who suffer from the same conditions come together to document their symptoms (and treatments) in excruciating detail.

Places like India, where females came together to challenge the extreme male Hindi power structure through online and offline activism, and who now speak with a common, group voice that India politicians can no longer ignore.

Places like Kenya, where in December 2007 the Ushahidi movement originated by Kenyan lawyer and blogger Ory Okolloh helped build an Internet mapping tool to allow people anonymously report violence via cellphone, and which was able to collect testimony of incidences of such at lightning speed.

Ushahidi was also used recently to help out in the Haitian and Chilean earthquakes.

Shirky suggested through these tales that there has been great progress. Ten years ago, we couldn't have even tried such things. Now, with these tools available, our motivation has swung to help one another.

Anything we formerly did in terms of intrinsic motivation was often with small groups. Now, we have the capability of doing revolutionary things on a much grander scale.

Moving ahead, the only question becomes, will we do them, or will we stand by and be paralyzed, as in Darfur, or Sarajevo, or other places around the globe?

Only time, and possibly a few revolutions, will tell.

DISCUSS   Digg   Del.icio.us   Reddit   Email This
Current display:       newest comments first       display in chronological order
lpricci49
IQ Crew
Sunday March 28, 2010 10:22:24 AM
no ratings

Thanks for sharing the informaiton with me ;-)

Lawrence Ricci
www.EmbeddedInsider.com

 

The ThinkerNet does not reflect the views of TechWeb. The ThinkerNet is an informal means of communication to members and visitors of the Internet Evolution site. Individual authors are chosen by Internet Evolution to blog. Neither Internet Evolution nor TechWeb assume responsibility for comments, claims, or opinions made by authors and ThinkerNet bloggers. They are no substitute for your own research and should not be relied upon for trading or any other purpose.
previous posts from Todd Watson
Todd Watson
Todd Watson   7/29/2010   Post a comment
IBM announced today it has entered into a definitive agreement to acquire Storwize, a privately held company based in Marlborough, Mass.
Todd Watson
Todd Watson   7/27/2010   1 comment
I watched with eager anticipation the premiere of the fourth season of Mad Men last evening.
Todd Watson
Todd Watson   7/22/2010   Post a comment
Today's a big day.
Todd Watson
Todd Watson   7/21/2010   Post a comment
If you've ever spoken to a computer voice over the phone and had it respond, there's a good chance you were speaking to an underlying technology developed by former TellMe founder Mike McCue.
5
of
IETV: the thinkerNet on film
5
of
2pm EDT
Thu
Sep 2nd
2pm EDT
Thu
Sep 30th
an IBM information resource
sponsored content
big blue blog
Todd Watson
Todd Watson   7/29/2010   Post a comment
IBM announced today it has entered into a definitive agreement to acquire Storwize, a privately held company based in Marlborough, Mass.
white papers & case studies
an IBM information resource
sponsored content
Getting to Work on Smart Work: How IT Is Transforming the Implementation of the 'Internet of Things'
Organizations in all industry sectors are becoming more instrumented, interconnected, and intelligent -- and that's changing the way they approach virtually every facet of their operations. It's up to IT to help organizations adopt a "Three I's" approach that leverages the emerging Internet of Things and enables them to work smarter.

READ THIS eBOOK
your weekly update of news, analysis, and
opinion from Internet Evolution - FREE!

REGISTER HERE
Wanted! Site Moderators
Internet Evolution is looking for a handful of readers to help moderate the message boards on our site – as well as engaging in high-IQ conversation with the industry mavens on our thinkerNet blogosphere. The job comes with various perks, bags of kudos, and GIANT bragging rights. Interested?

Please email: moderators@internetevolution.com
Internet Evolution – not for thickies
Steve Saunders' Outernet
A Hulu Lulu

Part 1 of 4   |  
See complete series
12|9|09   |   2:22   |   6 comments


Hulu is spectacularly popular with users and a total disaster for its owners. What the flegnog do they think they're doing?
The Sole Man
Shiver Me Timbers

7|26|10   |   2:21   |   No comments


Digital pirates find easy pickings in the open waters of the Internet. Aaarrrrrr!
Steve Saunders' Outernet
Internet Evolution Goes Soccer Crazy

1|28|10   |     |   14 comments


Steve Saunders visits the South African Consulate in New York for a party celebrating not one, but two (2!) major football (soccer!) tournies.
Thus Spake Mr. Cramer
3D: It's Baaaaack!

1|22|10   |   3:25   |   10 comments


3D was a pointless, silly gimmick 50 years ago, and it's a pointless, silly gimmick still. It's sure to catch on.
what.the.ferraro
A Bug in Pandora's Box

12|2|09   |   1:52   |   10 comments


Nicole describes a loophole in Pandora's music service, which lets users dodge the 40-free-hour limit. Shocking!
Sweeney Blog
Better Web Video & the End of Net Neutrality

12|1|09   |   2:32   |   7 comments


As long as the feds require treating all Internet traffic identically, online video will maintain sub-standard quality.
Full Nelson
iPad Unboxed

4|5|10   |   4:17   |   7 comments


It's flat and shiny. And Fritz likes it.
Reiter's Block
How Good Is ‘Kindle for BlackBerry’?

3|9|10   |   03:27   |   4 comments


Reiter's a readaholic and couldn't wait to get Amazon's Kindle for BlackBerry application. But was it worth the wait?
Second Shooter
Online Video’s 'Three Thirds' Problem

2|16|10   |   2:13   |   4 comments


Free online video was supposed to kill cable. But research shows most people are getting less interested in replacing cable with online video – not more. There are three reasons why, says Tom Nolle.
Thus Spake Mr. Cramer
Hive Life

2|10|10   |   3:01   |   12 comments


We do love our social networking, but, according to computer scientist Jaron Lanier, we may be diminishing ourselves when we join the hive. “May be? Ha!” says Mr. Cramer.
Sweeney Blog
Tweets Show West Is Best

7|30|10   |   2:47   |   No comments


Hey, Eastern Timezoners: Lighten up! Or at least Tweet happier thoughts.
Reiter's Block
Inside RIM’s Tablet Survey

7|29|10   |   2:50   |   2 comments


Research in Motion recently emailed a survey about smartphone use and tablet computer preferences. Could it be a prelude to a RIM tablet? Of course!
Second Shooter
Let’s Make Up Our Minds on Copyright

7|29|10   |   2:07   |   2 comments


There's a public-policy war on copyright that nobody is winning, and inconsistencies in viewpoint and interpretation seem to be multiplying. We need to step back and think our policies over again, or we risk having a strategy that fails everyone.
The Sole Man
Cloud-Based Video Sharing: Not Promising

7|28|10   |   2:49   |   1 comment


Ultraviolet is an industry-wide attempt to standardize video content delivery across multiple platforms. Apart from the fact that it’s based in the cloud, relies on the DRM system, and isn’t backed by Apple… it sounds great!
Wisdom of the Big Chair
Using the Web to Clean the Gulf

7|28|10   |   2:12   |   3 comments


The Internet played a key role in disseminating information and helping with the Gulf cleanup. Bravo, Internet!
Second Shooter
The Third Way or the Highway

7|27|10   |   2:09   |   4 comments


The FCC's Sixth Broadband Report has a hidden secret. But here’s a hint: The regulatory body plans to regulate broadband as a telecommunications service.
Singer at C-Level
I Predict You Will Watch This Video

7|27|10   |   1:59   |   No comments


Wouldn’t it be great to be able to predict what your customers want before they know they want it? Check our our latest tutorial about Predictive Analytics to find out how: www.internetevolution.com/tutorial-predictive-analytics.asp
The Sole Man
Shiver Me Timbers

7|26|10   |   2:21   |   No comments


Digital pirates find easy pickings in the open waters of the Internet. Aaarrrrrr!
Cirque Du Solez
Spontaneity Gives New Meaning to 'On the Road'

7|26|10   |   1:46   |   6 comments


Once defined by epic journeys, planning, and maps, the phrase "on the road" takes on new meaning in a digital age, where we can make all our decisions using our connected devices en route.
what.the.ferraro
Facebook the Movie... Awful

7|23|10   |   2:39   |   6 comments


Nothing quite says jumping the gun like making a movie about a six-year-old company.

Enabling People and Organizations to Harness the Transformative Power of Technology