The Macrosite for News, Analysis and Opinion about the Future of the Internet
Todd Watson

The Coming Social Media Train Wreck

Written by Todd Watson
4/25/2009 4 comments
DISCUSS   Digg   Del.icio.us   Reddit   Email This   TWEET THIS

Everybody likes a good train wreck.

Hopefully, of course, those where nobody gets hurt.

But when I was a kid, growing up in the sticks of north Texas, I'll never forget the first train wreck I stumbled upon.

Unfortunately, I didn't get to actually see the cars come crashing down off the railroad trestle.

But the aftermath was pretty powerful, in and of its own right.

Twisted steel, splintered and broken railroad ties, spilt cargo... it was awesome.

Of course, I'm sure Southern Pacific didn't agree, and heaven help them, it was a mess to clean up afterward that took them weeks.

That's what I expect the coming social media train wreck is going to look like.

I've been here in Orlando at the Forrester Marketing Forum for several days now, and it's been fascinating to hear all the talk about social media amongst a largely traditional marketing crowd.

This, of course, 10 years after I first read Cluetrain Manifesto and when the first glimmer of insight that this shift was already beginning to occur.

When I would tell colleagues about the book and about what was starting to happen, explaining that this was the future of marketing, they would look at me like I'd dropped in from another planet.

Maybe I had. But I also wonder now what their Twitter IDs are.

If you haven't read Cluetrain, and you want to be a social media practitioner who can help your business enter into the market conversation, run to your nearest bookstore and buy a copy.

Because context is everything.

When I first read the Cluetrain theses online, it made sense to me, particularly at the time, because I was starting to see the power and empowerment that the strength in connected numbers could bring.

The mass in mass media was going to be rendered increasingly impotent by the singularity of social media, the one-to-many equation would soon be equalled by the one-to-one.

Those who historically didn't have a voice soon would be able to, affordably and without prejudice.

The economics of scarcity (spectrum, channels, media outlets, high production costs) had been replaced by the economics of abundance (lower costs of bandwidth, storage, processing power, production tools, etc.)

Watching some of the traditional media and marketing entities, then, over these past couple of weeks jump onto the Twitter bandwagon has been downright amusing to me.

Not because they, like everybody else, shouldn't have the opportunity to tap into the social media.

No, rather, because so many of them seem to be missing the entire point.

Oprah and Ashton and so many others already have a voice.

This was never about a race to the million subscriber finish line.

It was about opening up a new way of communicating, between institution and individual, about evolving the monolithic top-down communication umbrella to a democratic megaphone.

Most importantly, though, it was about listening.

As the cluetrain.com Website conveys to this day, where markets are conversations, "Their members communicate in language that is natural, open, honest, direct, funny and often shocking. Whether explaining or complaining, joking or serious, the human voice is unmistakably genuine. It can't be faked."

For those attendees of the Forrester forum, as well as companies around the globe wrestling with their emerging lack of control of the market conversation going on about their business, rather than worrying about whether or not you're using Twitter, you might be better putting your efforts towards determining whether or not you have something to say, and someone intelligent and thoughtful and eager to listen to others to say it for you.

In other words, don't fake it.

Don't pretend.

Don't think just because you got a Twitter account or you put your company on Facebook that you suddenly get it.

No, those steps were only the beginning.

Now it's time to open the kimono a bit and actually tell us something.

Enlighten us.

Show us the smart people way down deep inside your organization and have them tell us something we don't yet know but should.

As Cluetrain went on to explain, "Corporate firewalls have kept smart employees in and smart markets out. It's going to cause real pain to tear those walls down. But the result will be a new kind of conversation. And it will be the most exciting conversation business has ever engaged in."

This is what Doc Searls and Christopher Locke and Rick Levine and David Weinberger understood and communicated, and it's what the rest of us ought not forget (although evidently which some of us never learned).

I don't know about you, but I'm certainly ready for a new kind of market conversation, especially coming out of the Great Financial Collapse of 2008.

A little brutal honesty and transparency and sunshine and liberation of new and more truthful voices is something we could all stand about now.

But while I wait for it to emerge, I'm going to enjoy watching the great social media crash as so many jump on the bandwagon with little thought to where or why or how they got here.

Because everybody likes a good train wreck.

— Todd "Turbo" Watson, blogger for IBM's On Demand Business Website

DISCUSS   Digg   Del.icio.us   Reddit   Email This
Current display:       newest comments first       display in chronological order
DHagar
Thinkernetter
Monday April 27, 2009 7:11:10 PM
no ratings

Great article and distinction in the use and value of true marketing.  Others will spend big dollars on getting all the bells and whistles and wonder why they never got the benefit.  They will have never caught the point to begin with - to listen!

Your strategic insight is excellent and the golden goose to companies and executives that will sit back and listen.

DHagar

 

Todd Watson
Thinkernetter
Sunday April 26, 2009 7:00:20 PM
no ratings

Chris,

Thanks for the comment, and congratulations on the 10th anniversary edition of the book.  It's hard to believe it's been ten years.

I got the markets as conversation religion when you spoke at SXSW Interactive in March of 2000.  I was also a speaker, on one of the panels, and I really enjoyed your session and went back to NY (where I was living at the time) and told everyone I could about the book and the message.

As for the comments problems, I'll ask our friends at Internet Evolution to look into what was causing you problems and see if they can't work that out.

If ever you're in Austin, look me up.  I also worked in the Internet division at IBM back in the late 90s, and I'm sure we would have lots to talk about.  You can reach me directly at turbotodd@us.ibm.com

Take care,

Todd "Turbo" Watson

Chris_Locke
Rank: Cave Painter
Sunday April 26, 2009 1:16:21 PM
no ratings

uh... it would seem that something is SERIOUSLY wrong with your processing of comments. that last was actually readable when I posted it. is this the "evolution" part? 

Chris_Locke
Rank: Cave Painter
Sunday April 26, 2009 1:12:52 PM
no ratings

thanksforpostingthis.howcouldinotconcur.<g> 

btw,a10thanniversaryeditionofcluetrainwillbeavailableinlatejune. 

http://amazon.com/cluetrain-10th-anniversary/dp/0465018653/

oooh,thisisthefirsttimei'veseenthenewcoverartthere!btw,sinceyourregistrationprocessdidn'taskmeforawebsite[replacedtest4]whynot?),here'stheone ispendthemosttimeworkingonthesedays.itmayseemafarcryfromcluetrain,butseemychapterintheneweditionforanattemptatconnectingthetwo.

http://mysticbourgeoisie.blogspot.com/

 

 

The ThinkerNet does not reflect the views of TechWeb. The ThinkerNet is an informal means of communication to members and visitors of the Internet Evolution site. Individual authors are chosen by Internet Evolution to blog. Neither Internet Evolution nor TechWeb assume responsibility for comments, claims, or opinions made by authors and ThinkerNet bloggers. They are no substitute for your own research and should not be relied upon for trading or any other purpose.
previous posts from Todd Watson
Todd Watson
Todd Watson   7/29/2010   Post a comment
IBM announced today it has entered into a definitive agreement to acquire Storwize, a privately held company based in Marlborough, Mass.
Todd Watson
Todd Watson   7/27/2010   1 comment
I watched with eager anticipation the premiere of the fourth season of Mad Men last evening.
Todd Watson
Todd Watson   7/22/2010   Post a comment
Today's a big day.
Todd Watson
Todd Watson   7/21/2010   Post a comment
If you've ever spoken to a computer voice over the phone and had it respond, there's a good chance you were speaking to an underlying technology developed by former TellMe founder Mike McCue.
5
of
IETV: the thinkerNet on film
5
of
2pm EDT
Thu
Sep 2nd
2pm EDT
Thu
Sep 30th
an IBM information resource
sponsored content
big blue blog
Todd Watson
Todd Watson   7/29/2010   Post a comment
IBM announced today it has entered into a definitive agreement to acquire Storwize, a privately held company based in Marlborough, Mass.
white papers & case studies
an IBM information resource
sponsored content
Getting to Work on Smart Work: How IT Is Transforming the Implementation of the 'Internet of Things'
Organizations in all industry sectors are becoming more instrumented, interconnected, and intelligent -- and that's changing the way they approach virtually every facet of their operations. It's up to IT to help organizations adopt a "Three I's" approach that leverages the emerging Internet of Things and enables them to work smarter.

READ THIS eBOOK
your weekly update of news, analysis, and
opinion from Internet Evolution - FREE!

REGISTER HERE
Wanted! Site Moderators
Internet Evolution is looking for a handful of readers to help moderate the message boards on our site – as well as engaging in high-IQ conversation with the industry mavens on our thinkerNet blogosphere. The job comes with various perks, bags of kudos, and GIANT bragging rights. Interested?

Please email: moderators@internetevolution.com
Internet Evolution – not for thickies
what.the.ferraro
Et Tu, Tweetus?

4|26|10   |   3:00   |   14 comments


Some theatrical productions are being reproduced in Tweeted format. Because, really, that's what we've all been waiting for, right?
Thus Spake Mr. Cramer
Hive Life

2|10|10   |   3:01   |   12 comments


We do love our social networking, but, according to computer scientist Jaron Lanier, we may be diminishing ourselves when we join the hive. “May be? Ha!” says Mr. Cramer.
Steve Saunders' Outernet
Internet Evolution Goes Soccer Crazy

1|28|10   |     |   14 comments


Steve Saunders visits the South African Consulate in New York for a party celebrating not one, but two (2!) major football (soccer!) tournies.
Steve Saunders' Outernet
The Death of Anonymity: Part 3

Part 3 of 4   |  
See complete series
10|28|09   |   1:35   |   4 comments


What can users today do to protect their online privacy? The simplest and most obvious option is to not use the Internet – at all. However, once all digital information is consolidated over the Internet, trying to protect digital identity by simply unplugging from the Internet becomes impossible – a fact that has manifest implications for civil liberties, Saunders says.
Steve Saunders' Outernet
The Death of Anonymity: Part 2

Part 2 of 4   |  
See complete series
10|27|09   |   2:08   |   8 comments


By 2011 the number of Internet-connected sensors will exceed 1 trillion, making your chances of doing anything or going anywhere unnoticed pretty much zero. Saunders talks about how the 'sensortization' of the Internet is eliminating the traditional divide between online and offline populations.
Steve Saunders' Outernet
The Death of Anonymity: Part 1

Part 1 of 4   |  
See complete series
10|26|09   |   1:29   |   13 comments


The 20th Century Internet was characterized by the ability to interact with other people and information on the Internet largely without anyone knowing who you were. The Internet of this century, conversely, will be defined by identity. Saunders explains how Internet users are unwittingly contributing to the demise of the anonymous Internet.
Steve Saunders' Outernet
Search Inversion & Profiling: Part 3

Part 3 of 3   |  
See complete series
10|21|09   |   1:40   |   No comments


Steve Saunders talks about the risks inherent in uncontrolled, widespread profiling of Internet users, and how one day this practice could form the basis of a new industry, the Outernet, which in economic terms will have outgrown the commercial value of the Internet itself.
Steve Saunders' Outernet
Search Inversion & Profiling: Part 2

Part 2 of 3   |  
See complete series
10|20|09   |   1:29   |   1 comment


Search companies and social networks are collecting incredibly detailed information about their users, says Steve Saunders, who predicts that these 'profiles' could one day become commodities to be bought and sold by companies on 'profile markets' or 'identity exchanges’ – the digital DNA equivalents of the financial and commodities exchanges on which stocks, oil, and gold are traded.
Steve Saunders' Outernet
Search Inversion & Profiling: Part 1

Part 1 of 3   |  
See complete series
10|19|09   |   1:52   |   6 comments


One of the most important Internet issues of all time is being ignored by the media. In this three-part video series Steve Saunders explains how search companies are turning the tables on their users by creating user profiles for financial gain, and how soon this trend will explode into full scale profiling.
The Incredible Hultquist
Social Networks & Hiring Pitfalls

10|16|09   |   2:16   |   5 comments


More companies are trolling social networks to find and vet potential job candidates. Beware the pitfalls of blurring the line between personal and professional lives.
Sweeney Blog
Tweets Show West Is Best

7|30|10   |   2:47   |   No comments


Hey, Eastern Timezoners: Lighten up! Or at least Tweet happier thoughts.
Reiter's Block
Inside RIM’s Tablet Survey

7|29|10   |   2:50   |   2 comments


Research in Motion recently emailed a survey about smartphone use and tablet computer preferences. Could it be a prelude to a RIM tablet? Of course!
Second Shooter
Let’s Make Up Our Minds on Copyright

7|29|10   |   2:07   |   2 comments


There's a public-policy war on copyright that nobody is winning, and inconsistencies in viewpoint and interpretation seem to be multiplying. We need to step back and think our policies over again, or we risk having a strategy that fails everyone.
The Sole Man
Cloud-Based Video Sharing: Not Promising

7|28|10   |   2:49   |   1 comment


Ultraviolet is an industry-wide attempt to standardize video content delivery across multiple platforms. Apart from the fact that it’s based in the cloud, relies on the DRM system, and isn’t backed by Apple… it sounds great!
Wisdom of the Big Chair
Using the Web to Clean the Gulf

7|28|10   |   2:12   |   3 comments


The Internet played a key role in disseminating information and helping with the Gulf cleanup. Bravo, Internet!
Second Shooter
The Third Way or the Highway

7|27|10   |   2:09   |   4 comments


The FCC's Sixth Broadband Report has a hidden secret. But here’s a hint: The regulatory body plans to regulate broadband as a telecommunications service.
Singer at C-Level
I Predict You Will Watch This Video

7|27|10   |   1:59   |   No comments


Wouldn’t it be great to be able to predict what your customers want before they know they want it? Check our our latest tutorial about Predictive Analytics to find out how: www.internetevolution.com/tutorial-predictive-analytics.asp
The Sole Man
Shiver Me Timbers

7|26|10   |   2:21   |   No comments


Digital pirates find easy pickings in the open waters of the Internet. Aaarrrrrr!
Cirque Du Solez
Spontaneity Gives New Meaning to 'On the Road'

7|26|10   |   1:46   |   6 comments


Once defined by epic journeys, planning, and maps, the phrase "on the road" takes on new meaning in a digital age, where we can make all our decisions using our connected devices en route.
what.the.ferraro
Facebook the Movie... Awful

7|23|10   |   2:39   |   6 comments


Nothing quite says jumping the gun like making a movie about a six-year-old company.

Enabling People and Organizations to Harness the Transformative Power of Technology