The Macrosite for News, Analysis and Opinion about the Future of the Internet
Craig Newmark

A Tipping Point in History Accelerated by the Internet

Written by Craig Newmark
10/1/2007 9 comments
DISCUSS   Digg   Del.icio.us   Reddit   Email This   TWEET THIS

A look back in time helps clarify what's happening with the ongoing evolution of the Net. The societal ramifications are far more important than the technology.

The Internet – that is to say, organized mass network communications -- started around 1450 with this guy, Johannes Gutenberg. The tech languished until a blogger, Martin Luther, created the first killer app, the Reformation. Luther made an informal "store-and-forward" network of churchmen, piggybacking on the Vatican network much as the modern Net piggybacked on the old phone network. During the Reformation, power flowed from small groups of people to slightly larger small groups of people.

During the 1600s, William of Orange sought the throne of England and prepared for that using the Net. Specifically, he utilized a network of bloggers, particularly John Locke, and distributed the blogs as pamphlets via a router network of coffee houses. John Locke et al, created a new killer app, modern representative democracy, with checks and balances.

William took power via the Glorious Revolution of 1688, so-called since it was relatively bloodless. During this transformation, power flowed from small groups of people to slightly larger small groups of people.

In the following century, the colonists in the America sought to redistribute power in a more explicitly democratic manner. Bloggers like Ben Franklin and Thomas Paine set the moral and political tone for the American revolution. Power was gained by even greater numbers of people.

However, the costs of printing and distribution, or of television, were too high for most people -- those ordinary people who are trustworthy and moderate. The expense limited mass Net communications to the already powerful, or those deemed newsworthy, often extremists. Warfare and terrorism were more telegenic than actual political discourse. Jon Stewart remarks that we hear more from extremists than moderates, because moderates have stuff to do.

The modern Internet, however, is everyone's printing press, particularly using those tools that require little or no technical knowledge to publish. Ordinary people are using the Net to work together to effect change. That is, the voice of the powerful and that of extremists is being replaced by the combined voice of moderates.

For examples, we used to say that history was written by the victors in war. However, Wikipedia is now the history of our time, written not by the powerful, but by the knowledgeable. While the powerful and others still attempt disinformation, ordinary people are building methods and technology to defeat that.

Similarly, in the presidential election of 2004, the powerful successfully used disinformation campaigns (including the Swiftboaters) using that term both literally and figuratively. However, moderates worked together in 2006 to counter disinformation effectively.

Also, the Howard Dean campaign used the Net to help moderates self-organize and to raise funds. This effort itself was premature, but influenced the elections.

With 2008 elections nearing, all serious presidential contenders are using the Net. A few are using self-organizing methods where supporters have considerable influence on the campaign. Both the Ron Paul and Barack Obama teams are using these methods well.

The folks at OneVoice provide a platform for uniting moderates in Palestine and Israel, with dramatic results. They've asked thousands of people what they want, and for the most part, people on both sides want a deal, but don't trust the other side. OneVoice gives everyone involved a voice, and they've become a mass movement.

Continuing a historical trend, moderates are gaining a collective voice to overpower the voices of extremism and abusive power, doing it via the Net. It's about the people, not the technology. And the Net brings people together in other areas, magnifying what people of good will can do together.

A number of organizations have been influenced by the microfinance work of Muhammad Yunus at the Grameen Bank. More than 7 million people have received small loans, which they've used to build small businesses. It's the fulfillment of the cliche about teaching a man to fish, rather than feeding him for a day.

Many people are participating in similar activities via the Net, for example through kiva.org or prosper.com, which provide loans for people with little or no collateral, and a high rate of payback. As loans are repaid, Kiva makes new loans to people in need.

In a sense, microfinance is the new Marshall Plan, an echo of the efforts that allowed Europeans the ability to rebuild industry and infrastructure after World War II.

Internet-based tools are also allowing people to better understand how their governments work, and how to hold them accountable.

For example, the Sunlight Foundation promotes the creation of simple databases, which document flows of money and contracts within the U.S. government. Such tools draw from difficult existing databases that show lobbyist contributions to politicians... and what legislation results.

Sunlight and related groups also helped write recent ethics reform legislation... and they are helping fix remaining problems.

Finally, researchers are using the Net to collaborate, via early and broad publication of results in their respective fields. This accelerates research in a number of vital fields, particularly in the molecular biology of disease. AIDS research has occured much faster than expected, and possible epidemics, including SARS, can be investigated much more quickly than in the past.

People are using the Net to change the whole direction of human history. All these efforts might just be combining to form a really big tipping point.

— Craig Newmark, Customer service rep and founder of craigslist.org

DISCUSS   Digg   Del.icio.us   Reddit   Email This
Current display:       newest comments first       display in chronological order
robin
Rank: Fire starter
Monday October 15, 2007 1:51:36 PM
no ratings
I'm thinking, Craig, that one might easily argue that your selection of 1450 as a starting point is entirely arbitrary. The technology or printing device certainly was unlike anything that came before. But technology, even in the form of pigments to be spread on the walls of caves or carved quills, are enablers of the larger process and purpose of communicating information. And that goes way back...

But this quibble is minor and your larger points are both valid and important. There is an enormous benefit to our species to be able to communicate openly, to be able to speculate on the consequences of our decisions, to wonder whether our decisions are our own, and to get at the truth of our circumstance...

There will always be those who want us to buy into their agenda. One person's disinformation is often little more than another's self-serving perspective. There will always be the believers whose failure to invoke critical thought is hobbled by their reluctance to step beyond their circle of comfort. People will always hear or read just exactly what they wish to hear or read...

But the Public Network -- assuming that it remains such -- will allow our species to know and understand. It may also be the source of our survival. Like all good things, though, there are some who would like to take us back from that tipping point...
Ray Le Maistre
Rank: Cave Painter
Wednesday October 3, 2007 4:12:25 AM
no ratings

OK, so online political strategies are starting to have an impact in the USA, but lets take a more global view. Let's look at the countries that are shaping up, because of their sheer scale and increasing impact on technology developments, to have a major influence on the macro political scene (and therefore impact on the each country in different ways).

China? Hmmm, some way to go there. An information society that is still controlled by the state. Recent reports suggest that the wealth of technical talent is being used to take a look at what other nations are up to (but who isn't doing that? James Bond should be virtual by now, no?).

India? More than 1 billion people, but only a few million have broadband. Mobile phone penetration is growing fast, but there's a limit to what can be done with 2G networks, low-cost handsets and little wireless data access.

Africa? Becoming more important, especially for China, which is investing a lot in that continent. And again mobile penetration is growing, but it's light years from having an online economy.

Russia? Be afraid...  

There's an awful lot happening online in politics, activism, research etc that is having a positive impact in a lot of ways, but don't we need greater universal Internet access and freedom of speech to reach a true tipping point? And when is that going to happen?

Look at Burma Yes, modern technology means we are much more aware of what has happened in the past week or so, but the outcome is still depressingly familiar.

yehudi

 

rustblack
Rank: Cave Painter
Tuesday October 2, 2007 12:49:35 AM
We should be thankful 100 million billboards per minute aren't launched from Eastern Europe to our beloved interstates.  That would be problematic.  Getting spam is bad enough.
Craig Newmark
Thinkernetter
Tuesday October 2, 2007 12:16:33 AM

My sense of humor is pretty dry, and yet I'm completely serious, and I appreciate your picking it up.

I don't think providing commenting is a free speech matter, but I could be missing a lot.

However, doing customer service I see that sometimes handling comments can be quite a corrosive matter, that's a big deal if you get any traffic.

Thanks!

Craig 

2Coasts
Rank: Cave Painter
Monday October 1, 2007 7:38:27 PM
no ratings

Communities on the Internet can exert tremendous influence whether for good or evil. The Internet is comparable to any of the past frontiers of human existence. Like other frontiers, lawbreakers are rampant. Nevertheless, the mostly good citizens of Earth do come together and accomplish great things. Relatively passive ways to contribute are available such as the cancer, anthrax, and smallpox research carried out with shared computing power by Grid.org.

Maybe the modern Internet came into being just in time to help mankind overcome the biggest challenges of the 21st century. Those of us who are connected cannot claim ignorance of the world's problems. Or if we manage to remain ignorant, then we have no one to blame but ourselves. The truth is easy to find for all. Many of us might not make a big contribution on our own, but each of us can contribute in some small way by becoming involved even in a small way. Use the technology you have at your fingertips to learn about how you can help solve those issues that concern you the most.

Rayno
IQ Crew
Monday October 1, 2007 5:32:14 PM
no ratings

I believe the historical parallel between Internet/Spam is Interstate/Billboards.

In the U.S., the Interstate system was built out predominately in the 1950s. And ugly-ass billboards blossomed. Eventually, people rebelled against billboards and laws limiting them became more strict. If you want to see what I mean, go down to Alabama or Florida where billboards sprout like weeds. What a difference! There was an article recently in the NYT about the new stringent regulation of billboards, and how now there is a developing rebellino people are decrying it violates their private property rights.

So you might argue that commercial freedom has some kind of cost on the aesthetic side. And probably the only way to limit a really "ugly-ass" experience is through regulation (i.e., banning or limited billboards on highways; or limited SPAM through CAN-SPAM).

What do all the Silicon Valley libertarians think of this balance? I would like to know.

greenbone
IQ Crew
Monday October 1, 2007 5:04:03 PM
no ratings

Craig,

....great perspective on communications throughout history and the undertone of speech struggling to be free.

I see the Net as the great equalizer, allowing democracy, justice, simple fairness, and opportunity to become asymptotically closer to "perfect". The Net wiggles through holes in the "walls" or leaps over borders to nurish, inspire, and empower the brains of citizens cut off or filtered in countries like China, North Korea, Cuba.

...that said, I'm left to wonder how we'll ultimately balance truly free speech with "tragedy of the commons" - like spam, spam, spam.

I'm wracking my brain to think of a historical parallel for spam.  I can only think of a ficticious instance in "The Life of Brian", when the Roman soldiers were trying to stop someone from writing "Roman's go home!" on the city walls.

...and the real "other side of the coin" is raised by a very funny episode of "The Chapelle Show" where Dave ponders what it would be like to visit the Net if it were a physical place.  (he depicted a Mall-like setting with people looting the music stores,  people swarming him with offers for things he doesn't want, until he's beckoned down a dark hall to see a tryst between a french maid and a goat... and...well, you get the picture).

 The Net can accelerate the best and the worst forms of communication.

 Free speech or Free Stuff?

I wonder which will prevail. 

  

dweiner
Rank: Cave Painter
Monday October 1, 2007 4:43:02 PM
no ratings

Great post, Craig ... and hilarious!

 

It's been very exciting to see how the candidates grapple with 'new' communications. No matter how innovative and creative anyone gets with these new communities, it's still about the content. Let's hope everyone remembers that ...

 

David Weiner 

barce
Rank: Cave Painter
Monday October 1, 2007 3:46:14 PM

Craig, it's interesting that you use terms that all the historical figures you've mentioned would have a hard time grok'ing. :-)

 Just wanted to add this footnote though... All the "bloggers" you mentioned blog in the style of David Winer. At his site, http://www.scripting.com/ , you cannot add any comments, in the same way that you cannot add comments that will be publicly available on Paine's "Common Sense" or Locke's works on government.

 

David Winer thinks that comments on his blog would somehow affect his freedom of speech. Do you agree with this? 

Cheers, Barce 

The ThinkerNet does not reflect the views of TechWeb. The ThinkerNet is an informal means of communication to members and visitors of the Internet Evolution site. Individual authors are chosen by Internet Evolution to blog. Neither Internet Evolution nor TechWeb assume responsibility for comments, claims, or opinions made by authors and ThinkerNet bloggers. They are no substitute for your own research and should not be relied upon for trading or any other purpose.
previous posts from Craig Newmark
Craig Newmark
Craig Newmark   5/20/2008   9 comments
Nonprofits embracing social change to promote their missions isn’t exactly new, but some groups are using the social Web to recruit, educate, and help people in novel ways. The payoff? Donors get to see the direct results of what they contribute, rather than just collecting another tax writeoff.
Craig Newmark
Craig Newmark   12/20/2007   5 comments
The Internet is a powerful medium for thousands of commercial groups and private-sector organizations whose members share common positions on public policy. But I see a disturbing growth in the number of Websites set up by front groups that pretend to independently promote the efforts of special interest groups.
5
of
IETV: the thinkerNet on film
5
of
2pm EST
Tue
Dec 1st
an IBM information resource
sponsored content
big blue blog
Todd Watson
Todd Watson   11/20/2009   Post a comment
While Google introduces its new Chrome OS (which I'm hearing will be widely available in one year?  Did I mishear that?), IBM announced 10 new products today to help companies using IBM System z mainframe technology.
white papers & case studies
an IBM information resource
sponsored content
Smarter Collaboration: How to Thrive in a Challenging Business Environment
Market conditions are changing faster than ever, and organizations need to improve their agility and adaptability in order to provide better service and improve processes. The ability to work with customers, business partners, and employees as effectively as possible - while at the same time holding down costs - is a key to success.

READ THIS eBOOK
your weekly update of news, analysis, and
opinion from Internet Evolution - FREE!

REGISTER HERE
Wanted! Site Moderators
Internet Evolution is looking for a handful of readers to help moderate the message boards on our site – as well as engaging in high-IQ conversation with the industry mavens on our thinkerNet blogosphere. The job comes with various perks, bags of kudos, and GIANT bragging rights. Interested?

Please email: moderators@internetevolution.com
Copyright © 2009 United Business Media Limited - All rights reserved.      About Us  |  Privacy Policy and Terms of Use  |  Contact Us
CMP Media LLC
Internet Evolution – not for thickies
Steve Saunders' Outernet
Global Internet Growth: Part 2

Part 2 of 2   |  
See complete series
10|9|09   |   2:28   |   No comments


Saunders predicts the decline and fall of America’s Internet empire, and explains how the Internet of the future will be multi-lingual as well as multi-national.
Steve Saunders' Outernet
Global Internet Growth: Part 1

Part 1 of 2   |  
See complete series
10|7|09   |   1:24   |   4 comments


Saunders explains how Internet users in North America are already vastly outnumbered by those in the rest of the world – a situation which is only set to accelerate.
Reiter's Block
Tweeting for Customer Support

11|18|09   |   2:20   |   No comments


When Reiter gets incensed over incompetent Verizon FiOS order-taking and support, he broadcasts it via Twitter. Did it do any good? How should your company offer Twitter support? Watch this for all the answers.
Not Dr. Phil
Internet & TV in Perfect Harmony?

11|16|09   |   2:22   |   3 comments


A new set-top offers an Internet experience without screwing up what we like about TV.
Tom Nolle
Meatballs & Monetization

11|16|09   |   2:00   |   2 comments


Meatballs aren't an obvious source of monetization for the Internet, but Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs may well be just that, and might also represent a new dynamic in the complex world of Internet content delivery.
Sweeney Blog
Microsoft's Relevance in the Windows 7 Era

11|13|09   |   2:17   |   3 comments


The release of Microsoft's newest OS raises the question of the company's relevance in an era when Google dominates applications and search, and Apple runs circles around Redmond with its gadgets and user interfaces.
what.the.ferraro
Developers Take Google to Task

11|5|09   |   1:53   |   7 comments


The Google backlash continues. After seeing their Project 10^100 submissions disappear into the bowels of a Google server farm, a group of irate developers has started their own site to re-collect and vote on the ideas.
Reiter's Block
Slobbering Over the N900

11|4|09   |   2:41   |   11 comments


Techies have been going crazy over the pending release of Nokia's N900 cellular phone, which incorporates a newly revised touch-screen operating system. Reiter's got one. Is the craziness justified?
Steve Saunders' Outernet
The Death of Anonymity: Part 4

Part 4 of 4   |  
See complete series
10|29|09   |   1:40   |   7 comments


In the final episode of this series about the death of Internet anonymity, Saunders describes how the Internet of the future will start to attain a level of intelligence that requires no human intervention. Scary.
Steve Saunders' Outernet
The Death of Anonymity: Part 3

Part 3 of 4   |  
See complete series
10|28|09   |   1:35   |   4 comments


What can users today do to protect their online privacy? The simplest and most obvious option is to not use the Internet – at all. However, once all digital information is consolidated over the Internet, trying to protect digital identity by simply unplugging from the Internet becomes impossible – a fact that has manifest implications for civil liberties, Saunders says.
what.the.ferraro
Facebook Lacks Social Skills

11|20|09   |   1:53   |   1 comment


Facebook's 'Suggestions' for users demonstrate how little social networking sites understand about true social relationships.
Singer at C-Level
Smart Grid Opportunities

11|20|09   |   2:49   |   No comments


Industry initiatives and government stimulus funds are giving enterprise software vendors a great opportunity to help build out and manage smart grid technologies.
Tom Nolle
Total Telephony Transcends Telepresence

11|20|09   |   2:11   |   2 comments


The problem with telepresence is that it's not universally accepted, because video calling isn't. While we can all do video calling, we also apparently worry too much about how we look. If we want HD telepresence in our future, we have to dress down, mess up our hair, and dive into our online life.
what.the.ferraro
ThinkerNet Wins Min's Award for Best Blogs!

11|19|09   |   1:13   |   4 comments


ThinkerNet wins the Min's award for 'Best Blogs' – Internet Evolution's fifth award this year!
Full Nelson
SanFran.gov

11|19|09   |   8:51   |   No comments


Fritz has an exclusive talk with the mayor and CTO of San Francisco about that city's latest e-government efforts.
Robert D. Atkinson
America Has Much to Learn About Digital Piracy

11|18|09   |   2:09   |   No comments


The US loses about $20 billion a year on pirated software, movies, and music. But public policy can help stem the tide of digital theft. For example, France has recently passed a 'three strikes and you’re out' law, whereby if after two warning letters an individual continues to download pirated software then his Internet access will be cut off. US policy makers should consider adopting similar policies.
Singer at C-Level
Connecting Stakeholders: Part 3

Part 3 of 3   |  
See complete series
11|18|09   |   2:09   |   No comments


Financial management planning does not need to include Voodoo economics, but it does help to tap into the knowledge base of your team through some sort of real-time system. We explore your options.
Reiter's Block
Tweeting for Customer Support

11|18|09   |   2:20   |   No comments


When Reiter gets incensed over incompetent Verizon FiOS order-taking and support, he broadcasts it via Twitter. Did it do any good? How should your company offer Twitter support? Watch this for all the answers.
what.the.ferraro
Dogster.com More Popular Than Gov 2.0

11|17|09   |   2:05   |   1 comment


A lot of attention is being paid to launching Gov 2.0 Websites, but these sites aren't attracting a lot of visitors.
Reiter's Block
Is the BlackBerry 9700 'Bold' Enough?

11|17|09   |   3:07   |   4 comments


The successor to the BlackBerry Bold 9000 – the Bold 9700 – will be available soon in the US. Is it worth upgrading? Reiter's got one, and offers advice.
TechWeb The Global Leader In Technology Media